Same-subcategory comparison

Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network AccessvsTwingate

Compare buyer fit, pricing, capability depth, and purchase constraints within one buying category. A higher score is not a universal winner.

Comparison summary

How to choose

These conclusions apply to this subcategory and the buyer conditions shown here. They do not make one product universally better.

Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network Access

Consider when

Mid-market and enterprise organizations modernizing private application access from broad VPN to least-privilege ZTNA
Cisco-centered environments using ISE, Duo, Secure Firewall, Catalyst or Meraki SD-WAN, XDR, Splunk, or Security Cloud Control

Check before choosing

Organizations requiring transparent self-service pricing or an entry below 50 covered users
Buyers seeking a self-hosted ZTNA control plane or a deployment without cloud service dependence

Full profile

Twingate

Consider when

Small teams needing an ongoing free ZTNA entry point
Individuals running non-commercial homelabs that need Business-level controls for up to 7 users

Check before choosing

Clientless private-application access
Self-hosted Controller and Relay requirements

Full profile

Dimension	Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network Access	Twingate
Pricing and trial	Secure Private Access Essentials Requires quote · per covered user · custom quote · minimum 50 covered users Secure Private Access Advantage Requires quote · per covered user · custom quote · minimum 50 covered users Secure Private Access Essentials and Secure Private Access Advantage are the two core ZTNA purchase packages. Both are licensed per covered user with a 50-user minimum, and Cisco Commerce calculates the quote from user count and term. Standard subscription term choices are 12, 36, and 60 months; annual and full-term prepaid billing choices are described, but they are not collapsed into one inferred commitment or payment state. Enhanced software support is required through a separate support SKU, with Premium available as an upgrade. Secure Internet Access combinations, User Protection Suite access, trials, add-ons, and attached Experience Insights are not additional SPA plans. Combined Secure Internet Access and Secure Private Access: Cisco permits SIA and SPA to be combined within one Secure Access subscription when both use the same Essentials or Advantage tier. This broader SSE acquisition adds internet and SaaS security and is not another SPA plan; no combined-package offer is repeated here. Cisco User Protection Suite: The User Protection Suite provides Cisco Secure Access alongside Duo and Email Threat Defense, with additional endpoint and ISE products in Advantage. It is a broader suite route rather than a duplicate Secure Private Access edition. Full profile	Starter Free · Up to 5 users Home $15 USD · per month · Non-commercial use; up to 7 users Teams $5 USD · per user · per month · Yearly billing · discounted · billed annually $6 USD · per user · per month · Monthly billing · billed monthly Business $10 USD · per user · per month · Yearly billing · discounted · billed annually $12 USD · per user · per month · Monthly billing · billed monthly Enterprise Requires quote · per user · per month · custom quote Starter is free for up to 5 users. Home is $15 per month for up to 7 users and is limited to non-commercial use. Teams is $6 per user per month when billed monthly or a discounted $5 per user per month when billed annually. Business is $12 per user per month when billed monthly or a discounted $10 per user per month when billed annually. Enterprise is custom-priced per user. Payment is generally prepaid, but no minimum commitment term is publicly established for any retained offer. Users, admins, pending and disabled users, and Service Accounts count toward licensing. DNS filtering is an optional add-on for Business and Enterprise, with no public amount. Full profile
Best for	Mid-market and enterprise organizations modernizing private application access from broad VPN to least-privilege ZTNA Cisco-centered environments using ISE, Duo, Secure Firewall, Catalyst or Meraki SD-WAN, XDR, Splunk, or Security Cloud Control Distributed organizations with private applications across on-premises data centers, public clouds, and multiple regions	Small teams needing an ongoing free ZTNA entry point Individuals running non-commercial homelabs that need Business-level controls for up to 7 users Organizations migrating gradually from remote-access VPNs
Not for	Organizations requiring transparent self-service pricing or an entry below 50 covered users Buyers seeking a self-hosted ZTNA control plane or a deployment without cloud service dependence Buyers that require every legacy, peer-to-peer, or non-ZTNA application to use application-proxy access rather than VPNaaS	Clientless private-application access Self-hosted Controller and Relay requirements Core-plan secure web gateway, malware inspection, or remote browser isolation
Source check	98/100	98/100
Key features	Application-specific private access with deny-by-default, identity-aware policy Client-based ZTNA for Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, and ChromeOS scope documented by Cisco Clientless HTTP and HTTPS access in both SPA packages Browser-based SSH and RDP in Secure Private Access Advantage Per-session access with continuous endpoint posture checking	Outbound software Connectors with automatic clustering Clients for macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS, Android, and ChromeOS FQDN, wildcard, IP, CIDR, TCP, UDP, ICMP, and port-scoped Resources Resource-level deny-by-default policies and split tunneling Identity provider, MFA, native posture, MDM, and EDR context
Cons	No public numeric price, currency, renewal amount, implementation amount, or support price is available The 50-covered-user minimum and required separate support SKU raise the entry threshold Term and billing choices are quote configuration states and should not be treated as one universal commitment	Users must install and run a supported Client the browser extension is not clientless. Clients older than 12 months are unsupported and cannot connect.
Category buying score	79	81Higher category-fit score
Rank	#4	#2
Context	Security & Privacy / Zero Trust Network Access (ZTNA) Software	Security & Privacy / Zero Trust Network Access (ZTNA) Software
Least-privilege access	88Deny-by-default, contextual least-privilege policy and per-session continuous posture checking enforce application-specific access instead of network-wide reach for private apps that fit the ZTNA model.	86Resource-level deny-by-default policies, split tunneling, and scoped Resource types support least-privilege access by limiting what a user can reach; the score reflects that the fact set shows strong policy control, while not all advanced policy constructs are specified.
Identity and device trust	83Integrates natively with identity infrastructure and continuous posture assessment, though advanced authentication features like Duo require separate licensing.	79IdP-backed identity, MFA, native posture, MDM, and EDR signals establish user and device trust, while enterprise IdP depth and endpoint-security integrations are plan-bounded to Business and Enterprise.
Application coverage	76ZTNA covers private applications reachable through client and clientless HTTP/HTTPS paths across on-premises, cloud, and multi-region designs, Advantage adds browser SSH and RDP, and remaining non-ZTNA applications are expected to use separate VPNaaS.	83FQDN, wildcard, IP, CIDR, TCP, UDP, ICMP, and port-scoped Resources cover private, public, cloud, and on-premises apps including SSH, RDP, databases, and web, without documented core clientless application delivery.
User experience and performance	74Multi-platform Secure Client access, clientless browser paths, and choice of cloud or supported local enforcement give flexible user connectivity options, while quantified latency or experience outcomes are not established inside the core SPA capability set.	79Peer-to-peer transport with globally distributed Relay fallback and split tunneling can keep authorized paths direct after Client connection, subject to Connector placement and Client currency requirements.
Security and resilience	84Outbound-only Resource Connectors, deny-by-default application access, continuous posture checks, and multi-region design options reduce inbound exposure and support resilient private-access architectures for covered applications.	81Outbound-only Connectors, automatic Connector clustering, deny-by-default Resources, and expiring Service Keys reduce inbound exposure, alongside the operational requirement to keep Clients within the supported 12-month window.
Administration and integrations	82Simplifies multi-tenant administration through MultiOrg capabilities and integrates directly with Cisco security ecosystems like ISE and SD-WAN.	79Admin API, Terraform, Pulumi, enterprise IdP automation, endpoint integrations, and S3 export support operational integration on higher editions, while DNS filtering remains a separately priced Business and Enterprise add-on.
Support and total cost	57Quote-priced per-covered-user licensing, a 50-user minimum, required separate support SKU, and no published numeric price or renewal figures keep total cost opaque and raise the commercial entry threshold for smaller or self-serve buyers.	74Starter is free for up to 5 users, Teams is $6 per user per month monthly or $5 annually billed, Business is $12 or $10 respectively, and Home is $15 per month non-commercial, with Enterprise pricing, priority support, and SLAs quote-based and no public minimum commitment term.
Full profile	Full profile	Full profile

Comparison summary

Most material score differences

These are the stored dimension rationales returned with each score. They explain the buyer conditions behind the gap without speculating about hidden model reasoning.

Support and total cost

17 pts

Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network Access · 57/100: Quote-priced per-covered-user licensing, a 50-user minimum, required separate support SKU, and no published numeric price or renewal figures keep total cost opaque and raise the commercial entry threshold for smaller or self-serve buyers.
Twingate · 74/100: Starter is free for up to 5 users, Teams is $6 per user per month monthly or $5 annually billed, Business is $12 or $10 respectively, and Home is $15 per month non-commercial, with Enterprise pricing, priority support, and SLAs quote-based and no public minimum commitment term.

Application coverage

7 pts

Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network Access · 76/100: ZTNA covers private applications reachable through client and clientless HTTP/HTTPS paths across on-premises, cloud, and multi-region designs, Advantage adds browser SSH and RDP, and remaining non-ZTNA applications are expected to use separate VPNaaS.
Twingate · 83/100: FQDN, wildcard, IP, CIDR, TCP, UDP, ICMP, and port-scoped Resources cover private, public, cloud, and on-premises apps including SSH, RDP, databases, and web, without documented core clientless application delivery.

User experience and performance

5 pts

Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network Access · 74/100: Multi-platform Secure Client access, clientless browser paths, and choice of cloud or supported local enforcement give flexible user connectivity options, while quantified latency or experience outcomes are not established inside the core SPA capability set.
Twingate · 79/100: Peer-to-peer transport with globally distributed Relay fallback and split tunneling can keep authorized paths direct after Client connection, subject to Connector placement and Client currency requirements.

Research basis

This page uses stored product facts, official evidence, and category scoring rationales. It is not an account-based hands-on test, and third-party user ratings are not folded into the category buying score.

Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network Access: Fact confidence: 98% · Fact checked: 2026-08-12
Twingate: Fact confidence: 98% · Fact checked: 2026-08-12

More tools

Zero Trust Network Access (ZTNA) Software

Add more tools from the same subcategory to this comparison. The page keeps up to 6 tools.

Cloudflare Access

Cloudflare Access is a cloud-delivered zero trust network access product for identity- and device-aware access to self-hosted, SaaS, private-network, and non-web applications.

Twingate

Twingate is a cloud-managed zero trust network access service that uses endpoint Clients and outbound Connectors to provide identity- and device-aware access to private, public, cloud, and on-premises Resources.

81Compared

Microsoft Entra Private Access

Microsoft Entra Private Access is an identity-centric zero trust network access service for per-app and broad private-resource access across on-premises, hybrid, and multicloud environments.

Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network Access

Cisco Secure Access Zero Trust Network Access is the private-application access capability sold through Cisco Secure Private Access Essentials and Advantage, with client-based and clientless access, continuous posture checks, contextual least-privilege policy, and cloud or local enforcement.

79Compared

Palo Alto Networks Prisma Access

Palo Alto Networks Prisma Access is a cloud-delivered secure access service edge platform that applies least-privilege access, continuous trust verification, and ongoing security inspection to private, internet, and SaaS application traffic.

Akamai Enterprise Application Access

Akamai Enterprise Application Access is a cloud-delivered Zero Trust Network Access service that terminates user sessions in the cloud and brokers least-privilege access to private applications through outbound-only connectors. It supports clientless browser access and EAA Client access, device-posture policy, global edge transport, centralized reporting, SIEM feeds, and APIs while keeping Akamai's internet security, MFA, microsegmentation, WAAP, DDoS protection, browser security, connectors, and services in their proper product or component boundaries.

Netskope One Private Access

Netskope One Private Access is Netskope's current ZTNA product for direct, policy-controlled access to private applications across data centers, private clouds, public clouds, remote users, campuses, and selected OT and IoT environments. It supports managed-device access through Netskope One Client and clientless browser access, with Publishers connecting application environments to Netskope's cloud service.

Zscaler Private Access

Zscaler Private Access is a cloud-delivered ZTNA service that brokers direct connections between authorized users and named private applications without placing users on the network. Current standalone packages cover managed-device access through Client Connector and browser-based access for unmanaged and third-party users, with advanced segmentation, inspection, isolation, resilience, and data controls packaged separately.

Fortinet FortiSASE ZTNA

Fortinet FortiSASE provides agent-based and agentless zero trust access to private applications through its Secure Private Access capabilities, with identity, device context, application policy, and continuous posture checks.

#10

Chrome Enterprise Premium

Chrome Enterprise Premium is Google's current integrated secure enterprise browsing, data protection, and zero trust application access offer; it was formerly named BeyondCorp Enterprise.

More comparisons